Cinema IRL

Amber Noelle & Scott Gerhardt · donecast.com

Cinema IRL drops you straight into the movie and asks the question, "what would YOU do?"In every episode, Amber and Scott (and the occasional guest) take movie plot points and run them through a real-life filter. What holds up, what falls apart, and what they'd actually do when things get messy.From impossible choices to wildly unrealistic storylines, they break it down, challenge each other, and uncover how these stories might play out in real life.Cinema IRL is smart, funny, and just the right amount of unhinged. (In case you're wondering about the dinosaurs on the movie posters, it was an inside joke that gained waaaayyyy too much traction. Rawr!)

304 episodes

9d ago latest

3x a week cadence

English language

▶ Play latestRSS feed Website Comedy Tv Film After-Shows

https://donecast.com/rss/cinema-irl/feed.xml

Episodes 300

E306 – The Odyssey - What Would YOU Do?
2d ago · 48:12
Amber and Scott tackle the monumental three-hour epic The Odyssey , finding themselves hilariously out of their depth as they navigate a landscape filled with centaurs, Hydras, and confusing mythological lineage. They share a laugh over the absurdity of Greek gods using their powers to produce giant one-eyed offspring, while simultaneously questioning why Odysseus would choose to antagonize a deity like Poseidon by blinding his son. The duo is joined by a colorful trio of special correspondents—Morty the werewolf, Jimmy the zombie, and Von Murder the vampire—who drop by to offer their own uniq
E305 – One Night Only - What Would YOU Do?
6d ago · 46:00
Amber and Scott dive into the high-concept premise of One Night Only , a film depicting a dystopian America where premarital sex is strictly outlawed by a government mandate, leaving citizens with only twelve hours a year to engage in intimacy. The duo spends time dissecting the absurdity of a society that relies on color-changing arm biosensors to enforce chastity, while simultaneously questioning the inevitable black market for condoms that would arise in such a restrictive world. Their conversation takes a turn into the bizarre as they analyze the film’s heavy-handed product placement and t
E304 – Cookie Queens - What Would YOU Do?
9d ago · 29:16
Amber and Scott dive into the high-stakes world of the documentary Cookie Queens , pulling back the curtain on the intense, multi-million dollar empire of the Girl Scout cookie season. They explore the blurred lines between leadership development and what one young subject bluntly identifies as child labor, all while marveling at the sheer logistics of moving 12,000 boxes of cookies in a single season. The duo also questions the bizarre evolution of cookie flavors, wondering why anyone would opt for a standard chocolate chip when the entire appeal of the tradition was once built on exclusivity
E303 – Motor City - What Would YOU Do?
11d ago · 26:25
Amber and Scott tackle the bizarre, near-silent experiment that is Motor City , a film so dialogue-starved that Scott’s intro contained more words than the entire movie combined. The duo finds themselves in a heated, humorous debate over whether the film's extreme lack of communication was a brilliant artistic choice or just a confusing narrative void. They also share a genuine moment of physical comedy, recalling how they sat in the dark clutching each other's hands during an intensely gruesome, claustrophobic fight scene inside an elevator. Some What Would You Dos from the episode: What woul
E302 – Moana - What Would YOU Do?
13d ago · 20:06
Amber and Scott take a deep, albeit sleepy, dive into the live-action version of Moana , a film that left them questioning Disney’s pacing and the necessity of so many musical numbers. Between Scott’s hilarious confusion over the film's lore and Amber’s struggle to stay awake during the slower stretches, the duo finds brief moments of amusement in the Rock’s performance and the catchy, Oingo Boingo-esque "shiny" crab song. Their critique of the film’s runtime and the baffling decision to have Moana face such heavy burdens as a young child provides a humorous look at the frustrations of a moder
E301 – Maddie’s Secret - What Would YOU Do?
16d ago · 42:05
Amber and Scott dive into the chaotic and often bewildering experience of watching Maddie’s Secret , a film that left them grappling with confusing casting choices and a tonal whiplash that made it difficult to discern if they were watching a campy comedy or a serious drama. The duo shares a hilarious, genuine moment of frustration over the film’s glaring script inconsistencies and the bizarre, passive-aggressive nature of the protagonist’s mother. Despite the confusion, they manage to find common ground in their shared disbelief over the movie's most jarring plot points. Some What Would You D
E300 – Gail Daughtry and the Celebrity Sex Pass - What Would YOU Do?
20d ago · 35:59
Amber and Scott dive into the chaotic, campy world of Gail Daughtry and the Celebrity Sex Pass , a film that turns the harmless "hypothetical" celebrity crush into a full-blown international incident. The duo dissects the hilarious absurdity of a movie where a simple trip to a Jennifer Aniston book signing spirals into global espionage and accidental hit-and-runs. They also share a genuine laugh over the film’s clever use of The Wizard of Oz motifs, noting how Jon Hamm’s character essentially plays the role of the Wizard, doling out favors to a group of seekers who are far too deep into their
E299 - Jackass: Best And Last - What Would YOU Do?
23d ago · 21:21
Amber and Scott turn their attention to the chaotic, death-defying legacy of Jackass: Best And Last , reflecting on how the cast has evolved from their reckless twenties into their fifties. They discuss the surreal nature of Johnny Knoxville’s career, marveling at how a group of people managed to turn self-inflicted bodily harm into a global entertainment phenomenon without a single fatality. The hosts also touch on the bizarre meta-reality of the film’s production, specifically the absurdity of witnessing a legend like Brad Pitt get "abducted" in broad daylight at a local hot dog stand. Some
E298 - Minions & Monsters - What Would YOU Do?
27d ago · 28:02
Amber and Scott dive into the chaotic, yellow-hued world of the film Minions and Monsters , questioning everything from the logistics of minion management to the bizarre reality of their Hollywood stardom. The conversation takes a sharp turn into office politics, as they analyze the unconventional leadership of the minion known as Dick and the questionable hiring practices of various "Big Bosses" throughout history. They also share a good laugh over the meta-narrative of the film, ultimately realizing they spent the entire episode dissecting a movie about the making of a movie. Some What Would
E297 - The Invite - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 30:14
Amber and Scott dive into the relentless, high-octane dialogue of the film The Invite , where the sheer volume of words spoken per minute leaves almost no room for silence. The hosts navigate the suffocating tension of a dinner party gone wrong, dissecting the manipulative gaslighting tactics used by Angela to force her husband into a social trap. Beyond the conflict, they touch on the deeper, more poignant themes of the film, specifically the existential realization that a stagnant relationship can sometimes feel like a slow-motion car crash. Some What Would You Dos from the episode: What wou
E296 - Supergirl - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 38:24
Amber and Scott tackle Supergirl , diving into the messy, grief-stricken reality of Kara Zor-El’s life as a displaced alien struggling to find purpose on Earth. The hosts trade barbs over the movie’s questionable tonal shifts, specifically questioning the necessity of gratuitous profanity and the dark, unsettling subplots involving child abduction in what is otherwise a superhero spectacle. Their back-and-forth captures the frustration of watching a potentially family-friendly action film veer into unnecessarily edgy territory, all while Scott tries to reconcile his confusion over the film's s
E295 – Couture - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 24:35
Amber and Scott dive into the bizarre world of the film Couture , a fashion-themed horror movie that somehow manages to combine high-end couture with a muddy forest setting. The pair dissects the film’s disjointed narrative, including the confusing intersection of a breast cancer diagnosis, a secret pharmacy school student, and a struggling writer. They also engage in a spirited debate over why models command such massive paychecks and whether the prestige of a famous face is truly worth the exorbitant price tag. Some What Would You Dos from the episode: What would you do if you were in a fore
E294 – The Death of Robin Hood - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 27:39
Amber and Scott turn their critical lens toward the grim, blood-soaked reimagining of the classic outlaw tale in The Death of Robin Hood . They grapple with the jarring transition from childhood memories of animated foxes to a story defined by gore, maces, and a protagonist who has long since traded his noble cause for pure, unadulterated malice. The duo finds themselves deep in a debate over the ethics of generational revenge and whether or not a lifelong villain can ever truly find redemption on his deathbed. Some What Would You Dos from the episode: If you were a remorseless outlaw who had
E293 – Leviticus - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 23:50
In this episode, Amber and Scott dive into the supernatural thriller Leviticus , a film that manages to blend high-stakes religious tension with the absolute absurdity of a "gay-away" curse. The hosts share a genuine laugh over the movie’s bizarre premise, where a simple crush turns into a life-or-death battle against an invisible, vengeful apparition. Between dissecting the questionable parenting of a mother who actively curses her own child and mocking the logistical nightmare of dating while being haunted, they explore the darker—and often more ridiculous—sides of teenage infatuation. Some
E292 – Toy Story 5 - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 47:01
In this episode, the hosts dive into the existential crisis that is *Toy Story 5*, dissecting a world where imaginative play is fighting a losing battle against screen time and digital isolation. From the heartbreak of children being bullied for keeping their toys to the absurdity of a potty-training device voiced by Conan O’Brien, the crew explores why today’s generation might be losing their grip on resourcefulness. It’s a nostalgic, slightly cynical, and deeply passionate look at whether we’re raising a generation of loners or just adapting to a new reality.
E291 – The Breadwinner - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 30:33
Amber and Scott break down the family comedy The Breadwinner , diving into why this film defies its low critical score to provide genuine, laugh-out-loud entertainment. They explore the comedic brilliance behind the movie's chaotic depiction of parenting, dissecting everything from the "instinctive" nature of household management to the bizarrely over-the-top physical comedy of a horse destroying a home. It is a refreshing look at how a film can succeed by simply knowing exactly what it is and leaning into its own absurdity. Some What Would You Dos from the episode: If you were Nate, would you
E290 – Scary Movie - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 17:11
In this episode, the hosts attempt to dissect the chaotic, spoof-heavy landscape of the *Scary Movie* franchise, though the conversation quickly devolves into a masterclass in technical incompetence and verbal stumbles. Between struggling to operate their own recording software and questioning why they even bothered to sit down for this recording, they manage to touch upon the Wayans family’s legendary history of pushing boundaries and the sheer absurdity of trying to find a "What Would You Do?" scenario in a film that thrives on disjointed nonsense. It’s an irreverent, slightly unhinged look
E289 – Pressure - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 21:48
In this episode, Amber and Scott dive into the high-stakes history of the film Pressure , which explores the harrowing meteorological decisions leading up to the D-Day invasion. They discuss the fascinating use of inflatable tanks and dummy parachuters as psychological warfare, highlighting how the Allies masterfully tricked the German forces about the actual location of the attack. Amber and Scott also share a laugh over the random trivia that Chris Messina, who plays meteorologist Irving Crick, is actually credited with creating the hashtag. Some What Would You Dos from the episode: If you w
E288 – Carolina Caroline - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 26:14
In this episode, the hosts break down the cinematic crime spree of *Carolina Caroline*, a film that proves small-town boredom is a dangerous catalyst for bad life choices. From questionable bank robbery fashion choices to the hosts debating the logistics of "suicide by cop," they dissect why our protagonists are essentially the worst criminals to ever grace the silver screen. It’s a cynical, hilarious look at why you should probably just stick to a 9-to-5 instead of trying to outrun the FBI with nothing but a wig and a dream.
E287 – Disclosure Day – What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 32:00
In this episode of Cinema IRL , Amber and Scott untangle the chaotic, puzzle-like narrative of Disclosure Day , a film that leaves them questioning everything from government cover-ups to the ethics of alien experimentation. They dive into the surreal experience of the protagonist, Margaret, whose sudden ability to speak foreign languages and tap into the intimate lives of strangers turns her world—and the broadcast booth—upside down. The duo shares a spirited debate over whether this cinematic journey is a profound piece of art or just a confusing, over-extended blockbuster that leaves the au
E286 – Hungry - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 32:29
The Cinema IRL crew dives into the cinematic swamp-fire that is *Hungry*, a film that asks the question: "What if we put a territorial hippo in Louisiana and gave it a bunch of targets?" From a high-maintenance "Karen" rocking stilettos in the bayou to a questionable plan involving gasoline and open flames, Amber and her co-host break down every bad survival choice made in this campy creature feature. It’s a wild ride through "what would you do" scenarios where the body count is high and the sympathy for certain characters is hilariously low.
E285 – Power Ballad - What Would YOU Do?
1mo ago · 32:01
The hosts tackle the melodic treachery of *Power Ballad*, a film that proves why you should never trust a former boy-bander looking for a solo hit. When wedding singer Rick (Paul Rudd) shares a heartfelt song during an all-night jam session in Ireland, pop star Danny Wilson decides to "borrow" it all the way to the top of the charts without a single writing credit. Between debates over elevator door advertising and the logistics of confronting a thief in a hot tub, the crew explores the fine line between musical collaboration and straight-up larceny. It’s a sassy breakdown of missed opportunit
E284 – Backrooms - What Would YOU Do?
2mo ago · 22:17
The hosts tackle the confusing, liminal-space nightmare that is *Backrooms*, a film that promises spooky furniture store portals but delivers mostly "WTF" moments and mashed potato anatomy. Between Captain Carl’s questionable DIY exploration and a therapist who definitely should have reported her client to the authorities instead of following him into a wall, the team tries to make sense of a plot that feels like a fever dream. It’s a sassy breakdown of why some mysteries are better left behind solid drywall, especially when they involve sentient memories and pirate-themed giants. And also why
E283 – I Love Boosters - What Would YOU Do?
2mo ago · 27:39
Scott and Amber are at odds this week over *I Love Boosters*, a film that takes the term "fashion victim" to a literal, skinless extreme. While Scott lives for the absurdity of teleporting vacuum bags and crooked skyscrapers, Amber is ready to take a nap through the "stupidity" of it all. From petty moguls buying out candy companies to soul-sucking demons and the $100,000 "meat suits" no one asked for, it’s a wild ride through the world of high-stakes shoplifting. Whether you’re a fan of the "so bad it’s good" genre or you’re with Amber on the "just plain bad" side, this episode covers every w
E282 – Saccharine - What Would YOU Do?
2mo ago · 30:56
In this episode, the *Cinema IRL* crew tackles the unsettling, body-horror flick *Saccharine*, a film that makes your average diet pill side effects look like a walk in the park. Hosts Amber and Scott dissect the medical student protagonist’s decision to reverse-engineer a weight-loss drug made from human bone ash, leading to a supernatural haunting that is as calorie-dense as it is terrifying. It’s an irreverent deep dive into the extremes of the beauty industry, the ethics of cadaver experimentation, and the absolute absurdity of sleep-eating through an entire kitchen.

Episodes

Reading the feed…

More Comedy shows

Cinema IRL

Episodes 300

E306 – The Odyssey - What Would YOU Do?

E305 – One Night Only - What Would YOU Do?

E304 – Cookie Queens - What Would YOU Do?

E303 – Motor City - What Would YOU Do?

E302 – Moana - What Would YOU Do?

E301 – Maddie’s Secret - What Would YOU Do?

E300 – Gail Daughtry and the Celebrity Sex Pass - What Would YOU Do?

E299 - Jackass: Best And Last - What Would YOU Do?

E298 - Minions & Monsters - What Would YOU Do?

E297 - The Invite - What Would YOU Do?

E296 - Supergirl - What Would YOU Do?

E295 – Couture - What Would YOU Do?

E294 – The Death of Robin Hood - What Would YOU Do?

E293 – Leviticus - What Would YOU Do?

E292 – Toy Story 5 - What Would YOU Do?

E291 – The Breadwinner - What Would YOU Do?

E290 – Scary Movie - What Would YOU Do?

E289 – Pressure - What Would YOU Do?

E288 – Carolina Caroline - What Would YOU Do?

E287 – Disclosure Day – What Would YOU Do?

E286 – Hungry - What Would YOU Do?

E285 – Power Ballad - What Would YOU Do?

E284 – Backrooms - What Would YOU Do?

E283 – I Love Boosters - What Would YOU Do?

E282 – Saccharine - What Would YOU Do?

Episodes

More Comedy shows

The Mr. Nailsin Show on Radio Misfits

The Bob Levy Show on the Radio Misfits Podcast Network

The Sean Widmer Podcast

Swimming With the Fish

ワクワクラジオ【10分ラジオ】

Keith and The Girl comedy talk show

Episodes 300

E306 – The Odyssey - What Would YOU Do?

E305 – One Night Only - What Would YOU Do?

E304 – Cookie Queens - What Would YOU Do?

E303 – Motor City - What Would YOU Do?

E302 – Moana - What Would YOU Do?

E301 – Maddie’s Secret - What Would YOU Do?

E300 – Gail Daughtry and the Celebrity Sex Pass - What Would YOU Do?

E299 - Jackass: Best And Last - What Would YOU Do?

E298 - Minions & Monsters - What Would YOU Do?

E297 - The Invite - What Would YOU Do?

E296 - Supergirl - What Would YOU Do?

E295 – Couture - What Would YOU Do?

E294 – The Death of Robin Hood - What Would YOU Do?

E293 – Leviticus - What Would YOU Do?

E292 – Toy Story 5 - What Would YOU Do?

E291 – The Breadwinner - What Would YOU Do?

E290 – Scary Movie - What Would YOU Do?

E289 – Pressure - What Would YOU Do?

E288 – Carolina Caroline - What Would YOU Do?

E287 – Disclosure Day – What Would YOU Do?

E286 – Hungry - What Would YOU Do?

E285 – Power Ballad - What Would YOU Do?

E284 – Backrooms - What Would YOU Do?

E283 – I Love Boosters - What Would YOU Do?

E282 – Saccharine - What Would YOU Do?